Skip to main content
Mechanics' Institute

Tarpey-Schwed LGBT Families Children's Book Special Collection

Contact Mechanics' Institute

Cover of Who's in a Family?.

Cover image from Open Library.

Image source

Who's in a Family?

Creator

Robert Skutch; illustrated by Laura Nienhaus

Date

Published 1997

Format

Book

A Tricycle Press many-family picture book that places same-sex parents inside a wider early-childhood family taxonomy.

Family diversityTwo mothersTwo fathersMixed-race familiesDivorceClassroom use

Overview

Who's in a Family? is Robert Skutch and Laura Nienhaus's many-kinds-of-families picture book, represented here through the 1997 Tricycle Press ISBN. Publisher, review, and library records describe a short book for young children that defines family through care across many household forms. The collection record notes two-mother, two-father, divorced, and mixed-race families, while publisher and trade-review sources place the book within a broad alternative-family taxonomy. The item is strongest as a family-diversity and classroom-legibility record. It does not center only LGBTQ families; instead, it places same-sex parents inside a larger early-childhood vocabulary for naming households, kinship, and belonging over time.[3][4][5][6]

A Many-Family Taxonomy

The book's basic strategy is enumeration. Publisher and review sources describe a survey of many ways families can be formed, including structures beyond a two-parent heterosexual household. That taxonomy gives the book its collection value. It offers young readers a vocabulary of comparison: some families are large, some small, some separated, some blended, and some led by same-sex parents. The structure is simple, but the simplicity is part of its usefulness for preschool and early classroom settings.[3][5][6]

Same-Sex Parents Within Breadth

The collection record explicitly identifies two-mother and two-father representation, and trade sources support the broader alternative-family frame. That placement matters because the book does not make LGBTQ families stand alone as the only difference a child must notice. It puts them beside divorced, mixed-race, single-parent, and other household forms. For a collection organized around same-sex-parent children's books, this is an important counterpoint to titles that focus on one family structure from beginning to end.[1][3][5][6]

Classroom Legibility

Publisher metadata frames the book for preschool and early elementary readers, and later public-school diversity disputes show how family-diversity books could become visible in curriculum conversations. The title appears in that broader record not because it has a documented ban here, but because it helped form the set of books adults selected when trying to name family diversity for children. The item therefore belongs near classroom recognition books as well as near ordinary family picture books.[3][7][8]

Creator And Illustrator Context

Publisher and Google Books metadata keep the creator roles visible. Robert Skutch is credited as author, and Laura Nienhaus is credited for the illustrations. Google Books also preserves a short author and illustrator context that places Skutch in writing and publishing work and Nienhaus in Bay Area art practice. That context is modest, but it helps explain why the book's plain early-childhood text and warm visual style work together to make family difference available without a long adult argument.[3][6][4]

Timeline

  1. 1981Earlier family-diversity titleMeredith Tax and Marylin Hafner's Families gives an earlier collection comparison.[9]
  2. 1995Earlier work trailGoogle Books metadata points to an earlier publication trail for Who's in a Family?.[6]
  3. 1995Google Books trailGoogle Books preserves a 1995 Tricycle Press metadata trail for the work.[6]
  4. 1997Tricycle Press datePenguin Random House dates the Tricycle Press edition to 1997.[3]
  5. 1997ISBN recordOpen Library records the 1997 ISBN 9781883672669.[4]
  6. 1990sTrade reviewPublishers Weekly preserves a trade-review record for the title.[5]
  7. 2006-2008Curriculum litigation contextParker v. Hurley sources place family-diversity books in a public-school dispute record.[7][8]
  8. 2009Later Tricycle comparisonMommy, Mama, and Me and Daddy, Papa, and Me provide later Tricycle/Penguin Random House comparisons for very young readers.[15][16]

Edition And Availability Trail

The held record is anchored to the 1997 Tricycle Press ISBN, with earlier work metadata and later publisher availability context.

1995

Earlier work metadata

Open Library work metadata preserves an earlier trail.

1997

Tricycle Press ISBN

The ISBN 9781883672669 record anchors this collection item.

2020s

Current publisher metadata

Penguin Random House metadata keeps the Tricycle Press record discoverable.

Explore Connections

Browse direct links, shared themes, and nearby publication dates.

Linked records

Earlier many-family lineage

Families

The 1981 Families record provides an earlier many-family comparison for Skutch and Nienhaus's later title.

References [9][3]

Spanish-language family-diversity peer

Familias

The Spanish-language family-diversity title gives a language-access comparison for books built around broad family categories.

References [10][3]

Broad taxonomy peer

The Family Book

Both books introduce many forms of family, though Skutch and Nienhaus use a quieter explanatory mode.

References [11][3]

Two-mother classroom peer

Asha’s Mums

Asha's Mums gives a more focused two-mother classroom comparison for the family recognition issues Who's in a Family? treats broadly.

References [12][3]

Shared themes

Two mothers

All Families Are Different

A nonfiction activity book that explains many family forms, including families with same-sex parents.

Two fathers

My Family, Your Family, Our Family

A community coloring book representing lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender parent families.

Two fathers

What Matters Most

A self-published many-family picture book about a child learning that family is defined by care rather than structure.

Two mothers

The Great Big Book of Families

A broad family-diversity survey that includes children with two mothers and two fathers.

Nearby dates

Published 1997

Celebrating Families

A Scholastic photo-illustrated nonfiction book in which children introduce many forms of family life.

First published 1997; local catalog year 1999

The Skull of Truth

A Magic Shop fantasy in which a truth-telling skull forces disclosures, including Uncle Bennie's gay identity.

Published 1996

Amy asks a question--Grandma, what's a lesbian?

A Mother Courage Press book that explains lesbian identity through a child's visit with her grandmothers.

First published 1996

Daddy’s Wedding

A pre-marriage-equality picture book about a boy attending his father and Frank’s commitment ceremony.

Citation

Who's in a Family?. Robert Skutch; illustrated by Laura Nienhaus. Tricycle Press, 1997. Tarpey-Schwed LGBT Families Children's Book Special Collection, Mechanics' Institute. Collection ID: KB-103.

Showing Plain text citation format.

Sources

Cover image from Open Library.

  1. Local collection catalog record for Who's in a Family? · catalog
  2. Research dossier packet_003 · internal
  3. Penguin Random House page for Who's in a Family? · publisher
  4. Open Library ISBN record for Who's in a Family? · library
  5. Publishers Weekly review of Who's in a Family? · review
  6. Google Books record for Who's in a Family? · library
  7. Parker v. Hurley legal source · legal
  8. ABC News context for Lexington diversity book dispute · news
  9. Open Library ISBN record for Meredith Tax's Families · library
  10. Open Library ISBN record for Familias · library
  11. Open Library record for The Family Book · library
  12. Freedom to Read challenged-work entry for Asha's Mums · access
  13. Two Lives page for ABC: A Family Alphabet Book · publisher
  14. Two Lives page for 123: A Family Counting Book · publisher
  15. Penguin Random House page for Mommy, Mama, and Me · publisher
  16. Penguin Random House page for Daddy, Papa, and Me · publisher